Mar 22, 2022

Catholics also reach agreement

On March 14, the Boy Scouts of America (BSA) confirmation hearing began to approve the reorganization plan following the BSA filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in February 2020. That filing came after a wave of individual child sexual abuse lawsuits. There were more than 80,000 claims from the past 80 years.

United Methodist congregations sponsor more than 6,000 Boy Scout troops. Since the bankruptcy announcement, United Methodists have been an important voice in the development of a reorganization plan, leading with compassion and care for survivors.

Negotiators for The United Methodist Church have reached a settlement in the Boy Scouts of America bankruptcy reorganization plan. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

A United Methodist Ad Hoc Committee (UMAHC) was formed to provide legal counsel in the bankruptcy and to advocate for United Methodist entities. A Leadership Team was also formed to assist with communication, allocation of a settlement, fund raising, and future relationships between congregations and the BSA.

The UMAHC included chancellors, bishops, general agency staff and attorneys. United Methodist leadership has been guided by five goals:

  1. Healing and support for survivors
  2. Releases from claims related to sexual abuse for United Methodist congregations that chartered Boy Scout troops and Cub Scout packs
  3. Releases from claims for all charter organizations
  4. Preservation of congregations’ and annual conferences’ insurance
  5. A fair and just financial settlement

UMC settlement details
The UMAHC reached a settlement to fulfill these goals. It includes:

  • a $30 million contribution to the Survivor Trust Fund;
  • training to help leaders meet with and hear the experiences and hopes of any survivor connected to a United Methodist congregation;
  • a review of all Safe Sanctuary policies;
  • education through a series of articles about how to ensure safety in youth programming; and
  • participation in a survivors’ justice and healing working group formed by survivors who filed claims.

All United Methodist annual conference leadership signed an agreement to give 100% support to the commitments.

Bishop John Schol

Bishop John Schol, who serves the Greater New Jersey and Eastern Pennsylvania conferences of The United Methodist Church, has been a member of the UMAHC and mediation team, and he led the leadership team. He shared testimony on Friday, March 18.  

Schol said the United Methodists’ goals included acknowledging and understanding the harm that abuse survivors have suffered, ensuring that their voices are heard, implementing policies to prevent future abuse, and providing compensation.

“We are sorry for what has happened to survivors throughout this time, and even this process,” he said, as his voice began to break. “We always wanted to make sure that the survivors were not a number, but that they were human beings, and that we would do everything we could to maintain the dignity of the survivors.”

Asked whether he thought the $30 million settlement was fair, Schol said there was nothing anybody could do for the survivors to make it fair. “What occurred to the survivors was not fair. All I can say is that we’ve done our best to work toward a just resolution,” he said.

Despite this compensation fund potentially being the largest aggregate sexual abuse settlement in U.S. history, it is clear that no amount of money can ever make up for the harm and abuse survivors had to experience.

Catholic leaders reach settlement
On the fifth day of the confirmation hearing, a committee representing several Catholic entities reached a settlement with the BSA and will withdraw its objections to the proposed reorganization plan. Nearly every Roman Catholic entity nationwide, including parishes, schools, dioceses, and archdiocese, would be considered “participating chartered organizations” in the BSA bankruptcy. That consideration would effectively release them from liability for all scouting-related abuse claims dating back to 1976 until the present. Claims prior to 1976 are subject to coverage by insurance companies after they reach individual settlements in trial.

While the legal proceedings may be completed soon, the process of healing and restoration will take much longer. Harm done to victims of child sexual abuse will never be undone. The church has much work to do to fulfill its nonfinancial commitments of healing, prevention and education. United Methodists will continue to lead with compassion and care.